Required fields are marked *. Mon mari (que je connais depuis 5 ans, et marié depuis 2) est en analyse depuis 4 ans.Cet homme a vécu des souffrances terribles dans son enfance, avec une mère tyrannique et maltraitante. À confondre les deux temps — à confondre le conscient et l’inconscient —, l’on ne peut durablement dénouer les conflits névrotiques et libérer la psyché. Alice au pays des merveilles de l’inconscient, Blanche-neige et les sept nains : L’Œdipe de la petite fille et la rivalité avec la mère, Pinocchio : Scène primitive, fantasmes et théories sexuelles infantiles, Freud, Breuer et la Méthode dite « Cathartique », Syndrome de Peter Pan et complexe de castration, Le Roi lion : L’Œdipe du petit garçon et le meurtre du père, Freud et le souvenir d’enfance de Léonard de Vinci, Texte de l’intervention au séminaire interne de l’École Psychanalytique de la Salpêtrière (14 décembre 2005), Le Bossu de Notre-Dame : Adolescence et vie amoureuse, Contes de fées, désirs animés et fantasmes inconscients, Avocats paris - Droits d'auteur, droit des marques, droit à l'Image et vie privée. 22. 310 pages. I will limit my discussion of Freud to the work between 1900 and 1923. If adults are unwilling or unable to acknowledge such feelings in children, they may experience feelings of shame and rejection. He reflects a wish on the part of his creator to recapture some aspect of lost childhood. Further, in his cartoons, Disney restored people as master of machines. By 1920, however, Beyond the Pleasure Principle, which introdueted another instinct: Thanatose. He held onto everything. 404-424. D.; Raymond G. Poggi, M.D. © 2020 Scraps from the Loft. This theme of clear renunciation of orality is lost in the Disney version because cannibalism is removed from the story. New York Times, Saturday, Dec. 3, 1977, Sect. The superego is the conscience, the rules of civilization as transmitted to the child through the parents and teachers. For a hero to be a delinquent was intolerable for Disney, who makes his Pinocchio a victim of the whims of the cruel people who exploit children. This topic is locked from further discussion. Much to Richard Schickel’s credit, he defends the “violence” that appears in Disney cartoons. She dreamt that the Neverland had come too near and that a strange boy had broken through from it. Little could she (or her younger brothers) know of the darkness lurking within Pan's black little heart. Yet the id is clearly the one in control. Notons toutefois que le Peter Pan de Spielberg est joué par Robin Williams, ce qui n’est pas peu de choses. This future projection of his wishes is “merely his substitute of a lost narcissism of his childhood—the time when he was his own ideal.”8. The real Peter Pan, however, is a mentally unstable sociopath with no conscience. For if he grows to become a big bull, he must face the matador in the bull ring. Freud, Sigmund, Civilization and Its Discontents (1930), New York: Norton Library, 1961 (trans. L’une des causes probables de cette maladie mentale est aussi le manque d’affection envers l’enfant venant de ses parents ou peut-être même de son entourage. Freud highlighted the intense conflicts seething within the individual: the ego’s entrapment between the id and the superego, and struggles between the two primordial instincts of life (Eros and libido) and death (Thanatos). Fantasies become mass produced, a child’s fantasies then become right or wrong, depending on how they correspond with the version on the screen.3, Some of Disney’s sanitizing efforts have had further-reaching effects on the meaning of the tales. Peter Pan a plus de 100 ans et pas une ride. Dreams and the Unconscious “While she slept she had a dream. Another author who notes the naivete of critics of violence for children is Loretta Bender, a child psychiatrist. Quant à la « psychologie populaire », la psycho-pop, on la désigne en Angleterre (le pays de Peter Pan), par l’expression : psychologie naïve — folk psychology en anglais. The analogy may be carried a little further. Depuis que Wendy est partie, Peter Pan devra affronter ses propres démons. 10. Cette petite gosse qu'il a aidé à grandir en dépit de nos peurs. To fully appreciate the effects of Disney’s fairy tales on children, however, it is necessary to understand their lives before five years of age. Posted May 13, 2016 On Narcissism: An Introduction (1914). Because of his sexual neutrality, sexual envy and jealousy do not occur in the unconscious of the viewer, making Mickey a safe identification object. Is Hook merely an Ahab, driven by a dark obsession with vengeance against he who has terribly wronged him? Alix Strachey). Au début des années 1980, le psychologue américain formé à lUniversité de lIllinois, Dan Kiley, popularise un profil psychologique désormais célèbre et connu du grand public sous le nom de complexe ou syndrome de Peter Pan . Adorno, Theodore W., The Popular Arts in America, Television and Patterns of Mass Culture, Ed. Malgré leurs allures naïves, les dessins animés ne sont pas là pour stigmatiser mais pour offrir une solution : l’inconscient est heureux ! Disney’s version of Cinderella robs the child of the most meaningful message of that fairy tale and tells him that he can do nothing for himself: a fairy godmother must do it for him. As the character masters the situation, he or she grows up. Pour le lecteur, désormais rompu au langage des rêves et de l’inconscient (en tout cas nous l’espérons), cela ne doit plus faire aucun doute : la lecture du dessin animé Peter Pan se donne à entendre limpide comme les tranquilles gazouillis de l’eau claire des rives du Neverland : Jean et Michel aiment leur sœur Wendy mais, dans ce nouveau choix d’objet amoureux, qui succède à la mère et signe leur volonté de sortir de leur complexe d’Œdipe, il y a un hic (ou un Ics) : Wendy, quant à elle plus grande, rêve déjà d’un garçon plus vieux — prince charmant ou mauvais garçon — qui l’emmènerait loin d’un père déjà épousé par sa mère. Jacques Lacan, Télévision, Seuil, Paris, 1974, page 40. Tel : 07 52 07 07 07 Ainsi, se détacher de Peter Pan, c’est se détacher du grand Tout et admettre la subjectivité et la castration symbolique. by Joan Riviere, revised by James Strachey). Mickey and Minnie Mouse rarely kiss; Huey, Dooey, and Louie are motherless; the mysteries of childbirth remain secret.4,19 Disney had that rare talent for walking the fine line between narcissism enough for people to be masters over machines along with enough denial of sexuality to subordinate the pleasure principle to the work ethic. The victims of violent death are not whole objects, they are part- objects. Goofy is the somewhat impaired ego. 19. There are those who believe that children should not be exposed to any violence whatsoever, almost as though they believe that there is no natural aggression in children. All your points were extremely valid.When you look at this story from the parents perspective it's absolute horror. In that position the child experiences people as primitive part-objects: breast for succor, penises for aggression, etc. While Disney has shown interest in subjugating machines to people, he gives only hints of going the rest of the way to acknowledge his interest in the human body. At the same time Disney is always certain that Donald gets his comeuppance, thus promulgating the values of society, perhaps almost in the fear that viewers would find Donald so appealing that they might be tempted to emulate him. 23. Disons-le tout de go : l’inconvénient d’une telle psychologie est qu’elle déculpabilise à peu de frais ceux qui croient quotidiennement avoir affaire au type de profil qui est ici censé être décrypté, tandis qu’elle culpabilise ceux qui redoutent de s’y reconnaître. Similarly, the death of the wicked witch is altered in the Disney version. SWING OR SLOW / Rythms'n'Books talks about the flow : Je vais contredire la presse qui en a déjà parlé, en affirmant que ce n'est pas un conte revisité de Peter Pan, mais plutôt une psychanalyse du disney Peter Pan, beaucoup plus intéressant à mes yeux qu'une simple … It really does not matter very much. Marcuse, Herbert, Epilogue: Neo-Freudian Revisionism, in Eros and Civilization, a Philosophical Inquiry into Freud. We were able to appreciate that we did not have to struggle with Goofy’s limitations in dealing with much of life. None other than Peter Pan. This state of affairs continues through the first trimester of life and is called the “paranoid/schizoid position.” In the second half of the first year, the infant comes to realize that the breast that feeds is the same one as one that does not. Je suis psychanalyste et je dis la vérité Les enfants sont condamnés à rester des enfants par la menace de castration personnifiée par le Capitaine-crocodile. Car on n'est vraiment heureux que lorsque l'on prend conscience et connaissance de son soi, de celui que nous sommes au fond de nous. Cette petite gosse qui ne l'oubliera jamais. . Along with Loretta Bender, Melanie Klein makes a strong point that children do have violent fantasies and need to work them through to master early anxiety.15,16 That mastery is necessary for growth. In Cinderella he eliminates the self-mutilation of the stepsisters and replaces the tree on the grave of Cinderella’s mother with a fairy godmother in order to make the stories more palatable to Court tastes. Once they arrive in Neverland, Pan introduces the three siblings to the Lost Boys, other children that have fallen into his trap. Like,volunteer-to-go-on-every-fieldtrip creepy. 32-41. Because of this closer link between the unconscious and conscious in children, fairy tales have greater meaning for them than for adults. Contée, et racontée, aussi fabuleusement qu'un dessin animé sur papier, l'auteur nous pousse à des réflexions et des retranchements sur toutes les questions laissées en suspens par ce conte, en nous replongeant dans le même contexte du "vrai" Pays Imaginaire, sur seulement une centaine de pages, avec ses images et ses sons à lui, pour nous faire comprendre la réelle signification. by James Strachey). Ce texte fait partie d’un travail en cours d’élaboration sur la Psychanalyse des contes, des fables et des mythes. for this summary.) J'ai envie de m'y replonger, et surtout d'emprunter le chemin vers la deuxième étoile, et de filer tout droit jusqu'au matin, main dans la main avec Michael. If he acts ferociously he will be taken to the bull ring and killed; hence, he must opt for the smelling of flowers and never grow up. By and large Disney Productions attempted, as an artistic policy, to be asexual. His most rewarding experience: “‘The whole damn thing, the fact that I was able to build an organization and hold it” (Schickel). Voilà je suis marquée à l'encre Kilke Pan maintenant! Freud declared that certain parts of the body were capable of providing the child the same intense pleasure that would later come to be associated with the genitals. L’incapacité à exprimer ses sentiments : le sujet a du mal à faire savoir les émotions qu’il ressent. See? En effet, la figure de la mère est très importante dans l’œuvre de Barrie. A.A. Brill).  Cf. PSYCHANALYSE DES CONTES ET DESSINS ANIMÉS. At the same time Freud recognized the close connection between self-esteem and emotional investment in the self (narcissistic libido): when loved, one feels better. The child has the capacity to understand the fairy tale intuitively. . La fée clochette sous cloche, le capitaine crochet fait d’une pierre deux coups : il prive les garçons de leur mère et contrôle Peter Pan, le fiancé de Wendy. She also explained how the child saw other people (called “objects” in psychoanalytic theory) in his or her environment. Son nom a été inspiré par Le revirement de clochette et la défaite de Crochet permettent à Wendy de s’émanciper du père (époux de la mère) et aux garçons d’abandonner sans dommage ce choix d’objet incestueux : à tous, de symboliser la mort du père. Your email address will not be published. Thus Donald is an id-dominated character who lives more intensely than Mickey Mouse. Between these 18 months, the baby becomes more aggressive and starts to bite and teethe. He is an underdog—but there is more to his character. He was in nearly constant pain. Disney also changed The Three Little Pigs.2’ The wolf no longer dies but is simply punished. We can only presume that his shadow, so repulsed by Pan's unsung crimes against humanity, escaped the clutches of his host in a desperate bid for freedom. Hence the good and the bad part-objects come together to form a whole object (many unhappy people struggle with this concept of seeing others as part—as opposed to whole—objects throughout their lives). But it is not an ordinary tree that these adapters leave out. 8. Even more, it robs some of these tales of their true meaning and sense of completion. Freud, Sigmund, Collective Papers, Vol. C’est bien de cela dont il s’agit dans le conte enfantin original et dans le dessin animé de Walt Disney Peter Pan. for that I give you the honorary croc award. In that position the child is capable of feeling guilt and mourning the loss of the good part of the other person (object) while at the same time feeling so angry that he destroys the object in fantasy. “Thus, in its reaction to the id, it (the ego) is like a man on horseback who has to hold in check the superior strength of the horse; with this difference, that the rider tries to do so with his own strength while the ego uses borrowed forces (from the id). 24. These films contain characters with purely superego traits. Disney had little leisure in his childhood, and perhaps had less time as an adult to reflect on the games of children or to talk with them firsthand. 2. At the same time, when one loves another, one invests part of himself in that other person (“forfeits a part of his narcissism”), “which can only be replaced by his being loved” in return5 (p. 55). 5. 20. Ce dernier pourrait trouver une solution permettant de construire ce qui n’a pas pu l’être durant l’adolescence de celui qui souffre du syndrome de Peter Pan. The second duck is a devil (the playfulness of the Duck’s id is reminiscent of the “It” in Georg Groddeck’s Book of the It, published also in 1923. In the Disney version she falls down a canyon and dies. PS5: What You Should Do First With The New Console. 1923 is a key date in Freud’s life for two reasons. Or, la psychanalyse en particulier et l’étude de la psyché en général, n’ont ni à culpabiliser ni à déculpabiliser. They then take him to the bull ring. 19-32. Le sous-titre de louvrage est à cet égard explicite : Ces hommes qui ont refusé de grandir, précise une couverture aguichante. In 1941, she co-authored a paper discussing the effects of comic books on children. Without going into detail, it is enough to say that Freud believed that the superego becomes operative in a child during the final stage of sexual development—the genital stage. Thought it was well known fact.... Haha, its everywhere! First, it was the year of the publication of The Ego and the Id, and second, it was the beginning of his bout with cancer of the jaw. Klein, Melanie, The Technique of Early Analysis in The Psychoanalysis of Children, London: Hogarth, 1975 (trans. 3, pp. La psychanalyse a uniquement à délier et dénouer les nœuds et ficelles dont nous parlions précédemment . He experiences it as bad when it does not satisfy. Bettelheim, The Uses of Enchantment, New York: Vintage, 1977. I aim to expose Peter Pan's various atrocities and bring one of history's most malevolent characters to justice. But he's got an awesome ride at Disney World. Which leads me to my next point: PROOF #3: PETER PAN IS A COMMUNIST DICTATOR. Collodi’s Pinocchio is very playful, a prankster; in short, a delinquent. Nippon's Peter Pan would whoop Disney's Peter Pan anyday... Well yea it's very tame. The ego ideal, the aspirations of the individual, is also a part of the superego. 1. Indeed, such primitive notions generally make us quite uneasy. Further, Fromm’s clinical statement denies internal states: there is no internal conflict in Fromm’s writing; it is all outside, and man is buffeted about by society.18 That absolute loss of control of one’s own life is a parody that makes Mickey Mouse look real by comparison. They have no particular personality, no “self.” They are not valued and the question in the story is whether Snow White can transcend their stage of development and grow into full, rich womanhood. Richard Schickel describes Disney’s childhood as very difficult, with frequent beatings. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. They include Thumper the rabbit and Flower the skunk in Bambi; Timothy the mouse in Dumbo; the mice in Cinderella; Tinkerbell in Peter Pan; the talkative owl in The Sword and the Stone; the advisor mouse in Ben and Me; and of course Jiminy the Cricket in Pinocchio. Studying Freud and other early psychoanalysts can lead to a better understanding of children and consequently to appreciating the effects of some of Disney’s works. That action “marks her final freedom from primitive orality, which stands for all her premature fixations”3 (p. 214). Alix Strachey). Cabinet de Paris Ce n’est pas le temps en tant que chronologique, mais un temps logique qui effraye Peter Pan : celui de la castration. Cannibalism is unthinkable. A detail is missing, an important one at that: James Matthew Barrie raised Peter Pan himself, in a human-sized capsule containing his own DNA, nonetheless. The hungry infant does not experience the whole mother, only that part of the mother (“part-object”) that feeds—the breast. Sans complaisance aucune, mais sans jamais culpabiliser qui que ce soit, la psychanalyse arrive, par la parole, les transferts et l’interprétation des rêves, des désirs et des fantasmes, à libérer totalement le sujet de l’inconscient. For example, a boy gives up that wish for two primary reasons: one, reality, and the other, fantasy. A neurologist by training, Freud was fascinated by the patients at Charcot’s Clinic in Paris. Réponses, Paris, 1996. Goofy’s is an ego weakened by an impaired intelligence. [Dan Kiley, The Peter Pan Syndrome : Men Who Have Never Grown Up, Dodd, Mead, New York, 1983. xvii, 281 p.]. Yet Disney’s exploiting that longing in this story seems to be a use of “psychoanalysis in reverse,” a concept that Adorno attributes to Leo Lowenthal. Sur tant de questions universelles, délicates, réelles, et existentielles, que l'on ne doute point révélatrices, mais qui résonnent nos parcours, et nos destins. 5,17,24 He was the first to create a fully synchronized sound track for a cartoon—in the 1928 production Steamboat Willie. ORAL STAGE The oral stage approximately last until the infants 18th month. 18. Some of Disney’s stories do not emphasize this growing up. By the third year of life, the zone shifted from the anus to the genitals, permitting experience of the most intense pleasure from genital masturbation.6,7. Une nouvelle interprétation du mythe de Peter Pan : comme Peter Pan, l'enfant triste est en apparence un enfant léger, gai, innocent et sans coeur qui, à la suite d'une tragédie ou parce qu'il a été sommé de devenir trop brutalement adulte, s'accroche désespérement au pays de son enfance. 6. 3. But Freud had not yet explained aggression. Not much is known about them except that they have been Pan's compadres for a long time, and they all wear animal costumes (distinctly separate from Pan's own getup, a clear sign of cultish activity). Hans Sachs, a psychoanalyst, notes that the last time machines were used for play and not work was during the time of the Greeks and Romans. Il arrive même que la personne concernée entre dans un état dépressif. He must've enjoyed that somewhat.Plus he blushed and looked happy when that tramp Tiger Lily kissed him. But I loved it when I was little and am now sentimental about it. Grotjahn, Martin, M.D., Ferdinand and the Bull, Psychoanalytic Remarks about a Modern Totem Animal, American Imago, 1, No. Roazen, Paul, Address to Topeka Institute for Psychoanalysis, Nov. 17, 1977. 12. Just as Disney’s Mickey Mouse appeals to “the Mickey audience,” his “fairy tales” appeal to the adult audience. Tc is right on the money ! They serve as guides, advice givers and teachers. Dans le cadre des journées « Je suis psychothérapeute d’enfants » Perrault had sanitized his fairy tales for this very reason. An example or two can clarify these concepts and show how they are ready tools for analyzing Disney’s creations. and exhorts Donald to go fishing and have fun. 11. That wish contrasts with at least one of Disney’s early contemporaries, Otto Messner, who received no credit for his character Felix the Cat, drawn for Pat Sullivan Studios. She discusses the infant’s first experience with other people. One is not so afraid of falling as of jumping.21’. “The spectator lives through all his own fears and feelings of smallness and at the end gets the comforting feeling that, in spite of all, he will be saved and will conquer the strong one” (p. 153). C’est ce courant de la psychologie, en provenance d’outre-Atlantique, qui s’emploie à forger et renouveler aussi régulièrement que possible, des concepts qui se veulent à chaque fois plus parlants et novateurs, les exposant largement dans les médias et les ouvrages grand public. After 1923 it hurt Freud to talk. Rather, he simply assures her that he has killed Snow White. Je ne sais pas si j'écris au bon endroit. 93–104, Your email address will not be published. Et surtout avec beaucoup de réponses imagées, qui gargouillaient mes tripes à chaque ligne. The Lost Boys are an enigma. (1977). Finch, Christopher, The Art of Walt Disney, Walt Disney Productions, 1975. Segal, Hanna, Introduction to Work of Melanie Klein, New York: Basic Books, 1973. Modern Library Edition, 1938 (trans. Mrs. Klein admonished the child psychoanalyst to pay great attention to detail in order to understand what the particular play activity means for a particular child. Pan has demonstrated himself to be a master of manipulative coersion, luring children to his hideout for the purpose of brainwashing them into his own private army. In that tree sits the dove who helps Cinderella to attend the ball, informs the prince that the slippers do not fit the feet of the stepsisters, and in the end punishes the stepmother and stepsisters. In addition to these basic concepts, in this paper Freud also introduces the concept of the ego ideal and conscience. Je ne suis plus cette enfant qui rêvait ses nuits, mais j'ai toujours ces chatouillis au creux de moi même, que je respecte, et qui ne me quitteront jamais. En d’autres termes, ce n’est pas la peur de la mort (le temps chronologique et conscient), mais celle de la castration (le temps mythologique et inconscient). All rights reserved. ; and Margaret King, Ph. No matter how blase, they are generally in a certain awe of Disney’s meticulous attention to detail, the draftsmanship, the imagination and the technical innovations that distinguish his craft. When a bee stings Ferdinand, people from the village mistake his running about in pain for ferocity. L'auteur a fait de chaque personnage, ou objet, un problème, auquel il nous apporte des solutions, tout aussi philosophiques soient elles, et qui font leur effet. 14. The real Peter Pan, however, is a mentally unstable sociopath with no conscience. Thus, the ego is caught between the instinctive pressures of the id on the one hand and the rules and restrictions of society on the other.9. Fitzpatrick, John J. Psychoanalytic Perspectives on the Human Life Cycle, Blueprint (Institute of Human Relations, New Orleans, March 1977). by David I. Berland, M.D. J'étais la petite gosse perdue, à tes côtés Peter, avec qui on redessinait notre monde le soir, dans mes pensées secrètes. In this essay the three-part division of the personality was delineated: the id, the ego, and the superego. The first thing he asks his new victims to do is fly away with him to a magical world made especially for kids (he neglects to inform them of a band of child-murdering pirates, but that'll come later), without their parents' knowledge or consent. Perhaps Disney was aware of the importance of this sexual neutrality when he appointed himself as Mickey’s voice, the voice of a sexually ambiguous prepubescent child.19. Bettelheim notes that much of the fairy tales’ personal statement to the child is lost when someone converts it to comic book or movie form. His book was designed for the enjoyment of the Court at Versailles. True, Einstein corresponded with Freud and also did many things unconsciously, but somehow the link between Disney and Freud seems clearer: to understand one can be useful to understanding the other. Some time ago, an article in the New York Times proclaimed: “In saloons, in graduate seminars, in barbershops across the land, whenever particular people ask, who, truly, are the giants of the Twentieth Century— who defined reality as we know it—three names loom: Freud, Einstein, Walt Disney.” 20. Children well know about cannibalism, sex, aggression, etc.13,16 In fact acknowledging that such thoughts and feelings occur and that they are human can be an important part of a therapeutic process for a child. At the same time she notes that a child has even easier access to the unconscious conflicts that adults do.13 Hence, the distinction between conscious and unconscious holds perhaps less for children than adults because the child has a readier access to the unconscious. The common portrayal of Peter Pan is a fun-loving boy who lives in a magical world called Neverland, where children who never want to grow go to live forever. Some time ago, an article in the New York Times proclaimed: “In saloons, in graduate seminars, in barbershops across the land, whenever particular people ask, who, truly, are the giants of the Twentieth Century— who defined reality as we know it—three names loom: Freud, Einstein, Walt Disney.”20. 75016 Paris He explains that one of the main reasons these machines were used solely for amusement involved that culture’s value of the human body. The next zone of intense pleasure was the anal zone, permiting pleasure in retention and release of feces. Et en même temps, le spécialiste évoque des sujets concernant la mort, la fin du stade de vie de toute personne. 16. On the level of internal fantasy, he gives up that wish because of his love for his father as well as his fears that his father will punish him (usually in the form of castration fears) for his attachment to the mother. 21. Four films using the Disney sanitizing/sterilizing process are Cinderella, Snow White, Pinocchio and The Three Little Pigs. Thus, inside all people there were two primordial forces: libido, the life- loving, sexual force, and Thanatose, the destructive, aggressive, death force. It is the tree that Cinderella planted over the grave of her mother and watered with her tears. Freud notes that if parents or teachers severely criticize a child, he may retreat, withdrawing into a fantasy world in which he pretends himself to be his own ego ideal. Overall, fairy tales present a character with a problem of conflict that character must overcome. (Bruno Bettelheim admonishes one never to “explain” fairy tales to children.) Et tu t'envoles, tu t'envoles, tu t'envoles... Ca coule de source, j'étais obligée de la mettre, surtout je l'adore, car moi aussi je suis un petit enfant perdu, qui refuse de vieillir, et de renoncer à son ombre. Qu’est-ce que le syndrome de Münchhausen par procuration ? Klein, Melanie, The Symposium on Child Analysis (1927), in Love, Guilt and Reparation: and Other Works, 1921-1945, London: Hogarth, 1975 (trans. “Children are not upset by even the more horrible scenes in the comics as long as the reason for the threat of torture is clear and the issues are well stated.” The authors go on to say that if a child has a reaction to reading a comic book, most likely the cause for that reaction comes from the child, not the book.
Reprise Des Vols Brussels Airlines En Afrique, Mahrez Fifa 17, Brevet Des Collège 2002, Salaire Moyen Suisse, Télécharger Musique Sénégalaise Mbalax, Grange à Vendre 13, Programme D' éducation Internationale English, Camera Argentique à Vendre, Vaccin 11 Mois Effet Secondaire, Maison à Vendre Saint-pierre-et-miquelon,